Scientists Widely Slam Studies That Claim Coronavirus Death Rate Might Be Far Lower Than Believed

Scientists Widely Slam Studies That Claim Coronavirus Death Rate Might Be Far Lower Than Believed


Studies out of Stanford University and the University of Southern California, which have not yet been peer-reviewed, claim California neighborhoods might have seen up to 80 times the number of coronavirus cases than initially thought based on antibody tests. These studies have actually come under fire by members of the scientific community, who state their methodology was flawed.

Covid 19 Testing in Holland

A health employee collects a blood sample from a client has part of a coronavirus antibody test in … [+] Brabant in The Netherlands.

SOPA Images/LightRocket through Getty Images


In early April, researchers from Stanford evaluated a non-randomized sample of 3,300 residents of Santa Clara County, California, for coronavirus antibodies, which are believed to reveal evidence that a person was contaminated with the illness at one point.

Based upon those outcomes, researchers say that of the county’s nearly 2 million homeowners, in between 48,000 and 81,000 people might have been contaminated with the infection at one point, which is between 50 and 85 times more than the main tally of validated coronavirus cases for that amount of time.

The findings could recommend that the infection might be far less fatal than previously thought– with a casualty rate of between 0.12%and 0.2%, it would be closer to that of the flu, which has a 0.1th rate.

A subsequent– but much smaller– first round research study, with less than 1,000 guinea pig, reported comparable findings in close-by Los Angeles County, with numerous thousands of cases approximated based upon the antibody tests while fewer than 13,000 had actually been verified on Monday, when the research study was released.

According to conclusions drawn by the Santa Clara research study, the virus had infected anywhere between 2.5%and 4.2%of citizens, while the Los Angeles study found 2.8%to 5.6%– but like all new research studies worrying coronavirus, neither have been peer examined.

The study has set off a firestorm online, with some statisticians, epidemiologists and other contagious disease experts calling the study “careless” and criticising the method, from the effectiveness of the antibody tests used to the size of the sample populations tested and how they were recruited to take part. The researchers’ own predispositions have likewise come under fire, based upon an editorial they wrote for The Wall Street Journal that questioned whether shelter-in-place orders were justified.


Skeptics have likewise noted the research studies’ mathematics appears not likely when used to other cities— in the case of New york city City, which has actually already seen about 0.1%of the population validated to have actually passed away from coronavirus, the research studies’ estimated death rate would suggest nearly every New Yorker has actually already been infected, an unlikely notion based upon the rate of brand-new cases, according to Wired


The research studies have actually hit a nerve as the U.S saw small demonstrations over coronavirus lockdowns across the country, with some demonstrators stating the threat of the virus has actually been overblown by the government and mainstream media. The majority of Americans still think people ought to practice social distancing, even if it continues to harm the economy. Los Angeles County is one of the areas of the U.S. hit hardest by the financial fallout of the coronavirus pandemic, with less than half of citizens self-reporting that they worked in a study released last week. According to Johns Hopkins University’s coronavirus tallies, Tuesday afternoon saw almost 789,000 validated cases in the U.S., with simply more than 2.5 million worldwide.


The outcomes of more antibody tests UC San Francisco started testing locals of rural Bolinas, California for antibodies today and is also working on an effort to test almost 6,000 locals of San Francisco’s Objective District. UC Berkeley is set to check 5,000 residents of the East Bay in May, while teams in Australia, Iceland, China, Italy and Germany have also been reported to be working on their own surveys The National Institutes of Health is likewise in the procedure of carrying out a study, which will not just try to find positive antibody results however likewise intends to gauge whether such outcomes suggest people are unsusceptible to COVID-19 reinfection, which stays an open concern.


Feud over Stanford coronavirus study: ‘The authors owe all of us an apology’( The Mercury News)

New Covid-19 Antibody Research Study Results Are In. Are They?( Wired)

Almost half a million LA County residents might have had coronavirus, scientists compete( The Los Angeles Daily News)

Demonstrations Of Stay-At-Home Procedures Spread– But Are Small In Size( Forbes)

Less Than Half Of Los Angeles County Citizens Report Having Jobs, Study Discovers( Forbes)

How Accurate Is Trump’s Claim That The U.S. Has A Much Better COVID-19 Death Rate Than Other Countries?( Forbes)

Full protection and live updates on the Coronavirus

Learn More


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here