A new US study has found that if you’re masking masks at home during the COVID-19 pandemic, then using a combination of two different fabrics and ensuring a good fit could offer the most effective protection.
Carried out by researchers at the University of Chicago and Argonne National Laboratory, the new study set out to investigate which fabrics are best for filtering the tiny respiratory droplets that are released when a person coughs, sneezes, speaks or breathes and which are thought to spread COVID-19.
The researchers looked at a variety of everyday fabrics easily found around the house including cotton, silk, flannel and polyester-spandex chiffon, which is a sheer, synthetic fabric often used for items such as evening gowns.
To test their effectiveness at filtering droplets, particularly the smallest ones called aerosols, the team used an aerosol mixing chamber to produce particles ranging from 10 nm to 6 μm in diameter.
A fan then blew the aerosol across various samples of fabric at a speed which mimicked a person’s breathing when at rest. The researchers then measured the number and size of particles in air before and after they had passed through the fabric.
The findings, published in ACS Nano, showed that when a single layer of fabric was used, the filtration efficiency ranged from five to 80 percent and five to 90 percent depending on the size of the particles.
However, when using multiple layers of fabrics, filtration efficiency significantly increased to more than 80 percent for smaller particles and more than 90 percent for larger ones.
The most effective combination for filtering out aerosol particles was found to be a layer of a tightly woven cotton sheet combined with two layers of polyester-spandex chiffon, which filtered out 80 to 99 percent of particles, depending on their size. In fact, the researchers say that this combination performed close to that of an N95 mask material.
If you don’t have any polyester-spandex chiffon to hand, then substituting this fabric with natural silk or flannel, or a cotton quilt with cotton-polyester batting, was found to produce similar results. The researchers add that cotton, which is the more common material used for cloth masks, performs better when it has a tighter weave, so try to choose a cotton with a higher thread count if possible.
However, whatever fabric you choose, the team also points out that getting the right fit is also important, with the results also showing that gaps caused by a bad fit could reduce the filtering efficiency of all masks by over 60 percent.
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, along with many organizations and governments around the world, recommend that people wear masks when out in public. However, many have questioned whether home-made attempts with everyday fabrics are useful in helping to prevent the spread of the disease.
Based on the new findings, the researchers conclude that masks made using a combination of readily available fabrics still have the potential to provide significant protection from respiratory aerosol droplets.